April 14, 2026

Renting vs Buying a House: The 10-Year Wealth Study

What Consumers Should Know About Each Path

Renting vs Buying a House: The 10-Year Wealth Study

Key Takeaways

  • 250 cities Buying beats down-payment investing
  • Nearly 80% Buying beats rent + invest
  • $1.55M Largest buying advantage

AD Mortgage conducted this nationwide study to compare two long-term financial paths for someone who already has enough cash for a down payment: buying a home today or continuing to rent a similar home while investing that capital instead. The goal was to move beyond the usual monthly payment debate and test what each path may look like over a 10-year horizon.

At a time when renting often feels easier in the short term, the more important question is what happens over time. In some markets, buying may still build substantially more wealth. In others, renting and investing the difference may be the stronger financial strategy. This study was designed to show where those lines are starting to separate.

Our goal with this study is to provide a clear, data-backed perspective on one of the most important financial decisions consumers face. By analyzing long-term outcomes, we aim to support more informed conversations between borrowers and mortgage professionals.

Max Slyusarchuk Max Slyusarchuk CEO at AD Mortgage

Renting vs Buying: What This Study Compares

This is a scenario-based comparison of two 10-year financial strategies for consumers who already have enough cash for a down payment (previously, we also analyzed how much time is needed to save for a down payment, along with lists of the most and least affordable cities across the country). To create a consistent nationwide sample, AD Mortgage selected the five most populous incorporated cities in each U.S. state, resulting in a dataset of 250 cities across all 50 states.

The study compares two paths:

  1. Buying a home today using a standardized ownership model
  2. Renting a similar home and investing the money that would have been used for a down payment, plus any additional monthly savings from renting instead of owning

This is not a prediction of future performance, but a scenario-based framework for comparing two financial strategies under standardized assumptions.

Scenario 1: Buying a Home

In the homeownership scenario, the buyer purchases a home using a 20% down payment and finances the remaining balance with a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage at 6.11%.

The model estimates:

  • the buyer’s monthly housing cost
  • the remaining mortgage balance after 10 years
  • the home’s projected value after 10 years
  • the amount of equity the buyer may hold at the end of that period

In simple terms, this scenario shows what homeownership could look like over the next decade if a buyer purchases today and stays in the home for 10 years.

Scenario 2: Renting and Investing

In the renter scenario, the person does not use the down payment to buy a home. Instead, that capital is invested in.

The analysis tests two renter paths:

1. Investing the down payment only

The renter invests only the amount that would otherwise have gone toward the down payment.

2. Investing the down payment plus monthly savings

The renter invests both the down payment and any monthly savings created when renting costs less than buying.

This scenario is designed to give renting a stronger long-term financial comparison, rather than assuming the renter simply spends the difference.

Methodology: How We Compared Renting vs Buying in 250 Cities

All source data was pulled on March 17, 2026, and reflects market conditions at that time.

The study uses current city-level home values and rents, a national mortgage-rate assumption, state-level home-price growth assumptions, and a long-term stock-market benchmark to build standardized 10-year comparisons across 250 cities.

To create a consistent nationwide sample, AD Mortgage selected the five most populous incorporated cities in each U.S. state. This approach ensures geographical balance and comparability across states, focusing on high-density housing markets where rental and ownership dynamics are most representative of active conditions. Cities are not weighted by population beyond the initial selection.

A few notes are important:

  • Home values are based on Zillow Home Value Index data at the city level
  • Rents are based on Zillow rent data at the city level
  • The mortgage-rate assumption is based on Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS). The model uses a 30-year fixed mortgage rate of 6.11%, current as of March 17, 2026
  • Projected future home values are based on state-level House Price Index (HPI) growth over the last 10 years
  • The ownership model includes a simplified annual housing-cost assumption equal to 2.5% of home value to reflect taxes, insurance, and maintenance
  • Homeowner equity after 10 years is calculated as: projected future home value – remaining loan balance
  • The renter-investment scenario is based on the S&P 500 total return index. The model uses a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 10.35%, calculated from the past 30 years of index performance, and applies it as a constant assumption over the 10-year horizon. This approach represents a simplified growth model and assumes reinvestment of returns over time.
  • The study compares modeled outcomes under fixed assumptions and is not personal financial advice.

Key Findings: Is It Better to Rent or Buy a House?

1. Buying Beats Investing the Down Payment in All 250 Cities

In every market in the study, the buyer ends the 10-year period with more housing wealth than the renter builds through investing the down payment alone.

That result makes sense. A homeowner is not only putting money into the property upfront. Over time, they may also benefit from home-price growth, while each mortgage payment can increase their share of the home.

That helps explain why buying still comes out ahead even in high-cost markets. In cities such as San Jose, CA, San Francisco, CA, and Kailua, HI, buying remains ahead of the down-payment-only investment scenario despite very high housing costs.

Top 5 cities where buying builds the most wealth

Top 5 cities where buying delivers the largest 10-year advantage over investing the down payment:

  1. Bellevue, WA – $1,549,171
  2. San Jose, CA – $995,237
  3. San Francisco, CA – $900,451
  4. Seattle, WA – $885,426
  5. Kailua, HI – $858,277

2. Buying Still Wins in 80% of Cities Against Rent-and-Invest

The study then tests a much stronger renter strategy. Instead of assuming renters only invest the down payment, this version assumes they also invest the monthly savings created when renting costs less than buying.

Even under that tougher comparison, buying still comes out ahead in 199 of the 250 cities analyzed – nearly 80% of the total sample. Renting plus investing comes out ahead in 51 cities.

This matters because it gives renting a much stronger financial case. Rather than assuming rent is simply “money thrown away,” the model assumes renters invest both their upfront capital and the monthly cost difference over time. Even then, ownership still holds an advantage in most markets.

Cities where renting and investing comes out ahead

The cities where renting plus investing performs best are concentrated in some of the country’s most expensive housing markets, including Kailua, HI, San Jose, CA, Pearl City, HI, Arlington, VA, and San Francisco, CA. In these markets, the monthly premium for buying can become large enough for a disciplined renter-investor to come out ahead over 10 years.

Still, those cities are the exception, not the rule. Across the broader dataset, the buy-versus-rent equation remains tilted toward ownership even when renters are modeled as disciplined long-term investors.

Closing note

This study is a scenario-based comparison built on standardized assumptions. It is intended to show how long-term outcomes may differ across markets, not to serve as personal financial advice or a prediction of future investment or housing-market performance.

Renting vs Buying a House: The 10-Year Wealth Study
Download the report

Fill out the form, and the file will be uploaded automatically